印度成为第四个登陆月球的国家；印度网友很骄傲_风闻

【来源龙腾网】

评论原创翻译：

@realhbk316

As an Indian, I say that this achievement belongs to all of humanity..no country has landed at the lunar south pole till now.

2607

作为一名印度人，我认为这一成就属于全人类;迄今为止，还没有一个国家登上过月球南极。

@cnnothingburgerletsgobrand6381

1

THAT’S ONE SMALL STEP FOR MAN, ONE GIANT LEAP FOR SCAMMER KIND.

56

这对个人来说是一小步，对骗子来说是一大步。

原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处

@xinyiquan666

1

its not india, its US that provided the remote control from NASA, and all equipment on the rover is bought from europe space agency,====NASA’s series of arrays on Earth known as the Deep Space Network were used by ISRO to track and communicate with the spacecraft throughout the spaceflight to the Moon. “Congratulations ISRO on your successful Chandrayaan-3 lunar South Pole landing!”

26

不是印度，而是美国，美国宇航局提供了遥控器，月船上的所有设备都是从欧洲航天局购买的，印度空间研究组织在整个登月飞行中使用了美国宇航局在地球上的一系列阵列（发射镜），称为深空网络，来跟踪航天器并与之通信。“祝贺印度空间研究组织的月船3号成功登陆月球南极！”

（译注：深空网络(Deep Space Network, DSN)，由美国国家航空航天局(NASA)建立，成为美国国家航空航天局喷气推进实验室(JPL)的一部分。它是一个支持星际任务、无线电通信以及利用射电天文学观察探测太阳系和宇宙的国际天线网络，这个网络同样也支持某些特定的地球轨道任务。它是地球上最大也是最灵敏的科学研究用途的通信系统。）

@xinyiquan666

1

also , no one has to land on south pole,

12

另外，没有人必须要降落在南极，

@Sameer-es9vs

1

@xinyiquan666 once again, western come claiming credits for someone’s work. You never fail to disappoint.

357

@xinyiquan666又一次，西方人来认领他人的作品。见怪不怪了。

@santeesawock6679

@xinyiquan666 Nearly 40% of scientists working at NASA are Indian, including the chief technologist.

268

@xinyiquan666在NASA工作的近40%的科学家都是印度人，包括首席技术专家。

@xinyiquan666

@realhbk316 no one would be salty to india

5

@realhbk316没人会酸印度；

@xinyiquan666

@santeesawock6679 no, never heard that, actually most engineers scientist in NASA are chinese, not indian,

7

@santeesawock6679不，从没听说过，实际上NASA的大多数工程师科学家都是中国人，不是印度人；

@ButterfatFarms

@xinyiquan666 Never heard of that either. NASA’s 17K+ workforce is 54.6% White, 16.6% Hispanic/Latino, 13.2% Black/African American, 11.2% Asian, and 4.5% unknown.

32

@xinyiquan666 也没听说过你说的这些。NASA的17000+工作人员中，白人占54.6%，西班牙裔/拉丁裔占16.6%，黑人/非洲裔占13.2%，亚裔占11.2%，还有4.5%身份不明。

@vyshnavm6951

1

@xinyiquan666 get your facts right dude

52

@xinyiquan666搞清楚你的事实哥们；

@Nt-nc9ps

1

@xinyiquan666 this is independent Moon mission evrything is made from Scratch here

46

@xinyiquan666这是独立登月任务，这里的一切都是从零开始的；

@michaelmorningstar8645

1

Like saying nobody has landed on a Tuesday.

4

这就像说没有人在星期二着陆一样。

@umjain2007

@vyshnavm6951 he is chinese, so his jealousy and frustration are justified he he he.

59

@vyshnavm6951他是中国人，所以他的嫉妒和挫败感是有道理的，哈哈哈。

@mikeomolt4485

Orbital insertion manoeuvres enabling a soft landing on the moon south pole isn’t like simply choosing a day of the week to land.

9

实现月球南极软着陆的轨道嵌入操作,可不像简单地选择一周中的某一天着陆那样简单。

原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处

@daisywick.movieguy

Alr let me clear out a few things for both the parties here. Saying inaccurate stuff is very common in arguments with no head or tail. I can see only hatred in this chat nothing else.Lets talk about the NASA and other leading space organizations. No wonder with that much experience, and budget pulling off these kinds of missions come at a higher success rate. The International Space Center, manned mission to moon, rovers to mars etc. all these are hard to achieve by a new player in the game. Not to forget the success rate of NASA is pretty high, whether it be Apollo missions, impact landers, etc. But India here is also an emerging player with very less budget and comparatively ISRO’s budget is only 7.7% of NASA’s budget. Operating on such low costs, with such innovative ideas should be appreciated. Factually All the components including launch vehicle, rovers, sensors, instruments were made by ISRO in India. The only foreign obxt on it was a NASA instrument which is passive laser retroreflector array ( LRRR). It is used to measure the distance between earth and the moon. In conclusions without any doubts the old players are very experienced with tons of missions than India, but disregarding this achievement by India is not patriotic, instead should be considered selfish and inhumane. It is a pretty great achievement for India, and obviously a lot of people have different opinions but facts do not change. Everything that was said here can by verified by anyone.Lastly I tried to be as neutral as possible, so I didn’t mention my country in any way or form, but yes I am an Indian but instead of berating like some people from both sides my judgement is not clouded. “Peace cannot be kept by force, it can only be achieved by understanding” -Albert Einstein

让我为双方澄清一些事情。在没头没尾的争论中，说不准确的东西是很常见的。我在这次谈话中只看到仇恨，没有别的。让我们谈谈美国国家航空航天局和其他领先的太空组织。他们有了这么多的经验和预算完成这类任务的成功率会更高。国际航天中心，载人登月，火星车登陆火星等。这些都是一个游戏新手很难做到的。不要忘记美国宇航局的成功率是相当高的，无论是阿波罗任务，冲击着陆器等。但是印度是一个预算很少的新兴国家，相比之下，印空组织的预算只有美国宇航局预算的7.7%。以如此低的成本运作，有如此创新的想法，应该受到赞赏。

事实上，包括运载火箭、火星车、传感器、仪器在内的所有部件都是由印空组织自己制造的。它上面唯一的外来物体是美国航天局的一个月球测距后向反射器(LRRR)。它被用来测量地球和月球之间的距离。毫无疑问，老玩家比印度更有经验，但是忽视印度的成就是不爱国的，相反应该被认为是自私和不人道的。对印度来说，这是一个相当大的成就，很明显很多人有不同的看法，但事实不会改变。这里所说的一切都可以被任何人证实。最后，我尽可能保持中立，所以我没有以任何方式或形式提及我的国家，但是的，我是一个印度人，但我的判断并没有像一些人一样受到双方的指责。

“和平不能用武力来维持，它只能通过理解来实现。”——阿尔伯特·爱因斯坦

@peterlongprong7521

yes.. but wasting money on space exploration that has already been established half a century ago when your country is OVERPOPULATED and dying from massive POLLUTION and gross negligence is outright irresponsible

是的，但是把钱浪费在半个世纪前就已经建立的太空探索上，当你的国家人口过剩，正在死于大规模污染和严重疏忽时，这是完全不负责任的；

@ppraish

（修改过）

@xinyiquan666 if nasa provided it, then it didn’t provide it for free. Also just providing technology is not important, but you also need brains as well to pull off this kind of a mission.

11

@xinyiquan666如果nasa提供了，那就不是免费提供的。同样，仅仅提供技术并不重要，因为你也需要智慧来完成这种任务。