IMDb：《新龙门客栈》影评_风闻

【来源龙腾网】

评论原创翻译：

--------------------------

An Interesting Remake of the King Hu Classic

非常有趣的胡金铨经典之作的翻拍

chinesefan

Some people may get this movie confused with the highly acclaimed 1966 original of the same title by the legendary King Hu(Come Drink With Me, A Touch of Zen). Although not as good as the original, this one has more action to appeal for younger audience and the additional character of the inn lady played by Maggie Cheung is great fun. And there was the immortal Brigitte Lin. Unfortunately, the plot and scxt(reportedly) suffered due to an eye injury caused on Brigitte’s eye during shooting and the producers need to rush the film’s completion for the festival time’s screening.

有些人可能会把这部电影和传奇人物胡金铨1966年广受好评的同名原创电影(《大醉侠》《侠女》)搞混。虽然没有原创好，但这部电影更能吸引年轻观众，而且张曼玉扮演的店主也很有趣，还有不朽的林青霞。不幸的是，据报道，由于在拍摄期间，林青霞眼睛受伤，而制片人又需要赶在电影节放映前完成这部电影，所以电影的情节和剧本受到了影响。

Not as successful in the box-office as Swordsman 2, not as good as the highly acclaimed and artistic Ashes of Time, and not a cult success like White Hair Bride, this movie is still fun to watch. (Incidently, all 4 starred Brigitte Lin, around the same time and I consider them the most successful of the 90’s Wuxia)

虽然这部电影的票房没有《武侠2》成功，不如备受赞誉的艺术大片《东邪西毒》好，也不如《白发魔女传》那么卖座，但这部电影仍然值得一看。(顺便说一句，这4部都是林青霞主演的，我认为他们是90年代武侠中最成功的)

------------------------

Enter at your own risk

请自行承担风险

buddybhupender

Most of us try many things in our lives at the suggestions of others because we value their opinions or we want to play safe. First part is good but the latter part sometimes backfires on us. Same happened with this flick. I am a great fan of HK martial arts movies especially with the historical background. I saw the ratings on IMDb and saw couple of reviews who praised the movie and i decided to watch it.

在生活中，我们中的大多数人会尝试很多事情，听从别人的建议，因为我们重视他们的意见，或者我们想稳妥行事。前面还是挺好的，但后面有些地方有时会适得其反，这部电影也是如此。我是香港功夫片的超级粉丝，特别是那些历史背景的功夫片。我看了互联网电影资料库上的评分，也看到了一些对这部电影的好评，于是我决定看一看。

And it backfired on me. This movie is based on Wire Works. To present things in new style all the main fighting sequences are full of wire stunts. Nothing original and it does not co-relates with laws of physics. The story is though original like many other Chinese Legends we have witnessed in the past or present but the screenplay tries to attempt a lots of things differently or way too entertaining from the directors point of view that nothing sticks with a viewer with his head on his shoulders. My dear director wire works with a logical explanation works but too much dependency on them during fighting sequences is not a proof of your creativity. Your story might work but it is a action cinema where real martial arts has disappeared and it is a total failure.

结果事与愿违，这部电影以“威亚”作为基础的，为了以新的风格呈现事物，所有主要的打斗场面都充满了钢丝特技。没有什么原创的，也不符合物理定律，虽然这个故事像我们在过去或现在看到的，许多其他中国传说一样具有原创性，但剧本试图尝试许多不同的东西，从导演的角度来看，太有趣了，但没有什么能让观众留下深刻的印象。我亲爱的导演用钢丝来塑造场景，但又过于依赖这些“威亚”，这很难体现导演的创造力。你的故事可能很有用，但它是一个动作电影，真正的武术却消失了，这是一个彻底的失败品。

For me it doesn’t deliver what other users are suggesting. A total waste of time. An average flick which we will forget (regret) as soon as we finish watching it.

对我来说，它并没有传达出其他观影者所讲的内容。这完全是浪费时间，一部我们看完就会忘记(后悔)的普通电影。