IMDB影评：《超体（Lucy）》（2014）_风闻

【来源龙腾网】

总分：6.4/10

评论原创翻译：

1、10/10 This is a complete myth! The fun part is: What if it was true?

10星 短评：这完全就是一个虚构的故事！而好玩的部分在于：万一这是真的呢？

This film has greatly polarized critics for its use of controversial concepts. I am a scientist and of course this movie gives me mixed feelings about its science. But I’‘‘’m sure about one thing, that this is fiction. I am able to watch a fiction movie, am I not?

这部影片因为用上了一些颇有争议的概念，收到了两极分化的评价。我是科学家，而这部片子在有关科学的方面，无疑给了我很复杂的感受。但有一件事我是很肯定的，也即它是虚构的故事。看一部科幻片，这个肚量我还是有的，不是吗？ 

Some people review this film negatively for its scientific value, ignoring the fact that this isn’‘‘’t a documentary. What are these guys comparing this film against? There is no comparison against real-world science here. If somebody makes a film about black holes, I expect it to be faithful to the latest research about black holes. If somebody makes a film about the Sun, I expect it to be faithful to what we know about the Sun. In contrast, a film about aliens can stretch our suspension of disbelief a lot more, because we know no real aliens to compare it about. And my my, how wide a range of alien species has been spawned by the film industry in all its years! The main concept in this film is equally flexible because it has been proved a myth years ago. Everybody knows that, director/writer Besson knows that. These negative reviewers miss the entertainment value of this film because of something they were expecting (harmony to actual science) that was never there since the film’‘‘’s inception.

有些人会因为这部影片的科学价值而作出负面的评论，无视了它不是一部纪录片的事实。这些人是把这部片子拿去和什么做比较了？这部片子和现实世界的科学是完全不可比的。要是有人拍了一部有关黑洞的片子，我会期待它能忠实于黑洞领域的最新研究。要是有人拍了一部有关太阳的电影，我会期待它能忠实于我们对太阳的认知。相反，一部有关外星人的电影能让暂停怀疑的状态绵延得更远，因为我们完全不了解真正的外星人，也便无从比较了。而且额的神呐，在整个影史中，电影工业可是炮制出了种类如此繁多的外星人种族呢！这部片子的主要理念也同样是见仁见智颇富诠释空间，因为这在多年以前就已经被证明为是一个神话了。所有人都清楚这一点，导演兼编剧的吕克贝松也清楚这一点。这些恶评者因为自己的期待而错失了本片的娱乐价值，而本片中他们所期待的东西从一开始就不存在。

（译注：“暂停怀疑”的概念（suspension of disbelief）是由英国诗人塞缪尔·泰勒·柯勒律治（1772-1834）创造的，描述的去欣赏具想象力的文学或戏剧作品所需的心态，后者是英国浪漫主义文学的奠基人之一）

Remember, critics and joes thought Boondock Saints, Donnie Darko, and Star Wars blew… yeah. Watch it for yourself. If you’‘‘’re a Luc Besson fan, you won’‘‘’t be disappointed.

你们可要记住，评论家和暖男们曾经认为《处刑人》、《死亡幻觉》和《星球大战》都拍砸了…现在怎么着。你们自己去看吧。如果你是吕克贝松的粉丝，你是不会失望的。

Bad-*** car chase, science-fiction, sex appeal my goodness, Morgan “the man” Freeman, Chow Yun-Fat worthy shootout, visuals that will blow your-effing-mind, and it didn’‘‘’t even take 2 sequels and a prequel to do it.

狠辣的飞车追逐、我的老天哦那性感劲儿、摩根弗里曼“大佬”、周润发式的枪战、能让你爽歪歪的视觉效果，而且它甚至都不需要靠2部续集和1部前传，就做到了这些。

What happened to people that used to enjoy movies?

过去那些享受电影的人们都哪儿去了？

原创翻译：龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.com 翻译：yzy86 转载请注明出处

3、8/10 Not a Documentary!!!!

8星 短评：这可不是纪录片！！！！

Check the genre of this movie, it says SCI-FI, which stands for science FICTION!! If I watched every sci-fi movie expecting it to correlate with real life physics then there would be no point of the genre. All these bad reviewers seem to be on the more intelligent end of the pole but isn’‘‘’t cognitive enough to realize they’‘‘’re NOT watching a documentary!!!! This is a good sci-fi movie, which kind of lets you imagine what you could do if you knew everything and could do anything. Obviously It’‘‘’s not possible because you would have to break the laws of physics to even get near that point but it’‘‘’s still good to wonder. Worth a watch if you like the genre.

检视下这部影片的类型，说是SCI-FI，指的是科幻片！！如果我看过的每部科幻片，都要指望它和现实中的物理学挂钩，那这个类型也便没有任何意义了。所有这些恶评者貌似都属于更聪明的人群，但他们的认知能力还不足以意识到他们在看的不是纪录片！！！！这是一部很赞的科幻片，它能让你去想象，如果全知全能的话，你能做出些什么。显然这是不可能的，因为为了能接近那种状态，你就不得不打破物理法则了，但畅想畅想还是很不错的。如果你喜欢这种类型的话，还是值得一看的。

4、4/10 Starts well, finishes poorly

4星 短评：虎头蛇尾

Disappointing movie towards the end. Starts off well, everything makes sense, everything is clever, logical and interesting. After a certain point in the movie everything becomes ridiculous, unrealistic and not enjoyable to watch. The idea behind the movie was good, execution was not. The characters were also a little bit boring in my opinion. The situation the main character found herself in had an array of extraordinary things to do and take advantage of but didn’‘‘’t. Not a lot out of the ordinary happened, main character worrying throughout and not taking advantage/playing around with the situation she was in. If you’‘‘’re a fan of logical “what ifs” like myself I would not recommend it.

电影临近结尾的部分很让人失望。开始的时候很棒，一切都合情合理，一切都很绝妙，符合逻辑，且颇有趣味。而当影片一过某个特定的时点，一切就变得荒唐、不现实，而且看着也没啥乐趣了。这部电影背后的理念很出色，而执行可就不那么出色了。在我看来，那些角色也有点无趣。主角身陷的处境，使得她能做出很多非凡的事情，也完全可以充分利用这一点，可是却没有。并没有发生很多异乎寻常的事情，主角从头到尾都忧心忡忡的，也没有充分利用她置身的情势，也不曾耍弄一二。如果你是像我这样讲求逻辑喜欢假设分析的人，那我是不会推荐它的。

5、Lucy took the drugs, Luc Besson got high…

未打星 短评：露西磕了药，吕克贝松爽歪歪…

Obviously the main purpose of Luc Besson with this was initially to please the audience. The poor scared girl who takes revenge on the bad guys that hurt her. But with the ridiculous premise “what can we do if we acquire the 100% of functionality of our brain” the movie tries to be philosophical and …fails miserably. What is the meaning of life? The purpose of humans?

显然，吕克贝松拍这种片子的主要目的，一开始是为了讨好观众。那个吓破了胆的可怜女孩对伤害了她的坏人展开了复仇。但本片试图攀附哲学而扔出的那个可笑的前提假设“如果我们开发了100%的大脑功能，我们能做出什么?”，很不幸地失败了。生命的意义是什么？人类的目标又是什么？

The problem is that Luc Besson’‘‘’s brain isn’‘‘’t capable to provide such answers.

这里的问题在于：吕克贝松的脑瓜没有能力给出这类答案。

When Lucy’‘‘’s brain is at 20% she’‘‘’s starting to control …tv signals! It’‘‘’s obvious that the writer will hit a wall by his own brain limitations. At 30-40% she has telepathic and telekinetic powers. Later she travels back in…time, and the way she controls it is with…swipe move as in a smartphone! What else is there? The writer couldn’‘‘’t think of anything else!

当露西的大脑开发到20%时，她开始能控制电视信号了！显然，编剧会因为他自己大脑的限制而撞到南墙。开发到30%至40%时，她解锁了心灵感应能力和念力。之后，她穿越时间回到了过去，而她只消用手滑拉两下就能操控这个法门，就跟滑手机似的！此处还有什么别的呢？这编剧想不出其他任何东西！

I am everywhere! It’‘‘’s now a cliché since Edgar in “electric dreams”. Johnny Depp has done it too! Well good for you.

我无处不在！自《电脑梦幻曲》中的埃德加使用过以后，现在这句话已经成陈词滥调了。约翰尼·德普也说过这话！好吧，你真行。

（译注:埃德加为1984年科幻喜剧片《电脑梦幻曲》中一台具有自我意识的电脑）

6、8/10 A mix of science and fiction?

8星 短评：科学和虚幻的混合？

（译注：所谓吸引定律，又称吸引法则，是指世间万物皆由能量或者振动频率组成，相同的振动频率相互吸引，并引起共鸣。人类的意识也是能量的一种）

God = a giant being who was, is, and ever shall be, trying to become conscious of Himself.

Humans = each tiny piece God broke off of Himself to create our individual selves.

Lucy = one piece of God (think = SOUL) that happened to have an opportunity to become conscious of itself.

神=一种伟岸的存在，过去现在以及未来都在试图意识到他自己。

人=是神为了创造我们的个体自我，把自己粉碎后的每一个小块。

露西=神的一小块（思考即灵魂），碰巧得到了意识到自己存在的机会 。

The end is Lucy breaking apart into billions of pieces because the physical no longer mattered. It was her essence… which is why she was able to be everywhere, like God.

结局是露西散裂成了几十亿个小块，因为物理定律已经无关紧要了。这就是她的本质…这也是为什么她能如神一般无处不在。

I can’‘‘’t believe no one gets this. Look into quantum physics, even just watch The Secret. All we are is energy. If we take this concept to the extreme and to fiction, Lucy is what we get!

我都难以相信居然没人悟到这一点。研究下量子力学，哪怕只是去看看《自然法则：吸引定律》也好。我们不过就是能量。如果我们把这个概念推向极端乃至虚构一番，我们最终得到的就是露西这样的存在！

I LOVE this movie. BTW.

顺便一说。我爱这部电影。

Then again I think deeply and on a big picture basis, so hopefully all these negative reviewers read this and feel like morons… because they are.

我要重申，我想得很深彻，而且是从宏观视角出发，所以希望所有那些差评者读到这篇的时候，会感觉自己就是个白痴…因为他们确实是。

It’‘‘’s not meant to “just” be a movie. You really think Morgan Freeman would’‘‘’ve signed up for this if it didn’‘‘’t have some deeper meaning? Look at his track record!!! Come on, people, use that gray mass between your ears!!!

它本不是为了“仅仅”作为一部电影而存在的。你真的认为，如果它没有更深层次的内涵，摩根弗里曼会加入本片？去瞧瞧他的过往记录吧！！！拜托各位哈，把你们两耳之间那些灰白色的团块（即脑）用起来啊！！！

Just saying. I love this movie. From a non-science, non-pop culture perspective. I love this movie from a transcendent perspective. The kind of POV that allows you to believe that nothing is a coincidence.

我只是说说而已。我大爱本片。我是从非科学、非流行文化的视角出发的。我喜欢这部电影，是出于超验的角度。这种观点能让你去相信没有什么是巧合。

8、9/10 A magnificent take on the theory of everything

9星 短评：对万物理论的壮美阐述

Lucy is an action thriller movie. Most of its screen time is taken by the fast moving action scenes and the display of super human abilities. However, despite its unscientific claim (10% of brain power) and somewhat shallow dialogue, there are moments in Lucy, where the scxt taps into really moving understanding of human condition. I guess these bits and pieces push the movie to a whole different level. If you leave the mindless shooting and “good guy & bad guy” stereotypes aside, Lucy is an impressive take on theory of everything. It really makes you think and more than that feel about the “oneness” of everything. That alone, is a really good reason to watch this movie. A real gem. Don’‘‘’t miss it.

《超体》是一部动作惊悚片。其屏幕时间有大半是被快节奏的动作场面和超人能力的展示占据。然而，尽管存在不科学的主张（脑力开发10%）以及略显肤浅的对话，在《超体》中还是有几个瞬间，其剧本挖掘到了真正触动人心的对人类处境的体察。我感觉正是这些零零碎碎的部分把本片推上了一个完全不同的高度。如果你能把无脑枪战和“好人VS恶人”的老套路放到一边，《超体》是对万物理论的一次惊人阐述。它真的能引人遐思，此外，还能摸索万物的的“合一”。仅此一点，便是观看本片的大好理由了。是真正的宝贝。不要错过哦。